AbsoluteHistory
  • Popular
  • Galleries
  • Recent
  • Trending

The Story Of Infamous Western Outlaw Doc Holiday Was Darker Than We Ever Knew

Kyle Kucharski  | 1 month ago

The American West is famous for its notorious outlaws — who robbed banks, trains, and stagecoaches — as well as bold lawmen who chased them down. But none were quite like Doc Holliday. He wasn’t as lawless as many others, but engaged in his fair share of gunslinging and gambling. His reputation endures thanks to the classic character in Tombstone, played by Val Kilmer. But in separating fact from fiction, historians found that there's a side to this legend that no movie or book has managed to capture.

Southern Born

Doc Holliday was born John Henry Holliday in Griffin, Georgia, on August 14, 1851. He had a cleft palate, which required surgery and impacted his speech.
Southern Born
Facebook / Doc Talk
His doting mother worked with him for countless hours on proper pronunciation, and eventually, they vanquished the impediment.

Great Life

Doc had a wonderful childhood. His father was a pharmacist and his mother was a dedicated caregiver and teacher, bestowing the importance of manners on him.
Great Life
Photo by Underwood Archives/Getty Images
He was also an excellent student, especially in math and science. He was also a big reader.

Becoming A Dentist

Sadly, his mom died in 1866 from tuberculosis. Doc threw himself into his studies to cope with her death, and his good grades got him into dentistry school at the University of Pennsylvania.
Becoming A Dentist
Photo by Oxford Science Archive/Print Collector/Getty Images
Doc graduated in 1872 and began working as a dentist. 

New Interest

When Doc was 22, he moved his practice to Dallas, Texas. It was a rowdy place.
New Interest
Wikimedia Commons / Conkling Studio
His business was steady, but Doc quickly grew distracted by another passion: gambling. He loved the nightlife and frequented the many saloons.

Getting A Reputation

Doc was an excellent card player, which he often combined with drinking and fighting. This soon eclipsed his dental practice.
Getting A Reputation
Hollywood Pictures
He was arrested for these activities, as well as for getting into a gunfight with the saloon keeper.

Finding Love

Texas was also where he met Mary Katherine Horony, or Big Nose Kate. She was an independent woman who danced, bartended, engaged in sex work, and was incredibly intelligent.
Finding Love
Wikimedia Commons / Phillips Collection Photography Studio
Kate and Doc got married at a dance hall, though their good times wouldn't last forever.

Another Outlaw Town

The newlyweds faced major trouble when Doc was accused of murder. Historians aren’t sure if he was guilty, but fearing for his safety, he and Kate fled to Dodge City, Kansas — another town filled with outlaws.
Another Outlaw Town
Wikimedia Commons / Btphelps
Though not all the company was bad.

Making Enemies

In Dodge City, Doc met fellow gunslinger, Wyatt Earp. Wyatt was a temporary deputy who'd made enemies from rounding up lawbreakers.
Making Enemies
Wikimedia Commons / American Experience: Wyatt Earp on WXXI-TV
A few of them rode into Dodge one night and attacked the Long Branch Saloon, where Doc was playing cards.

Saloon Fight

Wyatt barged in when he heard the commotion. The gunmen aimed at him, but Wyatt surprised the attackers by backing up Doc with his own gun.
Saloon Fight
Photo by MPI/Getty Images
After this incident, the two became great friends. Eventually, the pair moved to Tombstone, Arizona, together.

Lucky For Them

Wyatt’s brothers were the marshals in Tombstone, and Wyatt picked up a job as a bank security guard. These enforcers couldn’t keep to themselves for too long and ran afoul of some cowboys who were also part-time outlaws. The Earps decided to arrest the Clanton and McLaury gang..
Lucky For Them
Underwood Archives/Getty Images

Legendary Shootout

Their feud came to a head on October 26, 1881 at the O.K. Corral.
Legendary Shootout
Robert Alexander/Getty Images
Nobody knows who fired first, but there was no doubt about the victims. Virgil Earp shot Billy Clanton, and then Doc shot Tom McLaury in the chest. Wyatt hit Frank McLaury.

Arrested And Charged

Everything happened quickly. Billy and the McLaury's were dead within 30 seconds of shooting.
Arrested And Charged
Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images
And soon after, Wyatt and Doc were arrested for murdering their rivals. Public favor was firmly divided about the crime.

Arrested With The Bestie

Though the vigilantes were in hot water, Wyatt himself was glad to be arrested with his best friend. He said Doc was the “most skillful gambler and nerviest, speediest, deadliest man with a six-gun I ever knew.”  .
Arrested With The Bestie
Wikimedia Commons

Divided Opinions

Some thought Doc and Wyatt were protecting themselves from a threat, and others heard the McLauries and Billy weren’t armed and were holding up their hands when they were shot..
Divided Opinions
Hollywood Pictures

Who Started It?

During the trial, witnesses provided conflicting accounts, based on who the witness was supporting. Even reliable third parties couldn’t agree on who started the attack..
Who Started It?
Photo via John Kobal Foundation/Getty Images

The Ruling

Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer presided over the trial. On November 30, 1881, the judge ruled that the accused couldn’t be convicted a crime because they were acting as lawmen and defending themselves..
The Ruling
YouTube / Leslie Derkovitz

Ruined Reputation

Wells also expressed his opinion that the men shouldn’t have been deputized at all. A few weeks later, a jury agreed to not convict the lawmen.
Ruined Reputation
Hollywood Pictures
Though they escaped formal punishment, socially their reputations took a major blow. 

The Gunslinging Dentist

Nationally, Doc Holliday earned a legendary reputation for being a gambling, gunslinging, dentist with manners and a well-kept mustache. People wanted to be like him — or maybe they had a crush..
The Gunslinging Dentist
Photo by John van Hasselt/Sygma via Getty Images

Western Drifter

After the public trial, Doc decided to flee from Arizona. He spent his remaining years drifting across the Western front, continuing to gamble.
Western Drifter
Wikimedia Commons / Internet Archive Book Images
At this point, he seemed to give up on the dentistry.

"This Is Funny"

On November 8, 1887, Doc succumbed to tuberculosis in Glenwood Springs, Colorado, at 36. In his dying moments, he took a shot of whiskey and said, “This is funny.” It can be difficult for historians to pinpoint the truth about Western heroes like Doc Holliday, but a recent rediscovery of a photographer's photos from Tombstone are giving us a much clearer picture..
"This Is Funny"
Facebook / The Adventures of Finius the Skinniest

Where it all began

With the legend of Tombstone already spreading across the United States, photographer C.S. Fly decided to capture the historic moments unfolding in the booming mining town.
Where it all began
C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons
In December 1879, he and his wife Mary arrived in Tombstone where they immediately set up a temporary photo studio inside a tent. In June of the following year, they opened this studio and gallery in their 12-room boarding house.

Behind enemy lines

In March 1886, Department of Arizona General George Crook learned that feared Apache leader Geronimo was prepared to meet with him. C.S.
Behind enemy lines
National Archives / CORBIS / Corbis / Getty Images
Fly caught word of the meeting and decided that he would accompany the military man to the historic encounter. Here is a photograph of an Apache council meeting being held by Geronimo himself.

Making a living

For much of the 19th century, Tombstone was a budding mining town. Here, we see the entrance to the ever-prosperous Tough Nut Mine.
Making a living
Carleton Watkins / Wikimedia Commons
This mine was owned by Tombstone founder Ed Schieffelin, along with his brother Al and partner Richard Gird.

The herd

John Horton Slaughter was a celebrated cowboy, lawman, and rancher, known for dedicating his life to the security of both Arizona and New Mexico. The men pictured here were members of John Slaughter's Ranch Outfit; cowboys tasked with bringing Slaughter's first herd to Arizona..
The herd
C.S. Fly / Buyenlarge / Getty Images

Apache May

In addition to his reputation in combat, John Slaughter was also known to be the guardian of a young Apache girl named May. While tracking a group of Apaches in Mexico, Slaughter stumbled upon this young girl, assuming she had either been abandoned by her parents or that they had been killed.
Apache May
C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons
Slaughter proceeded to adopt and care for her as his own.

Place your bets

Between all the gold, silver, and copper mining, the residents of old west Arizona sure knew how to make the most of their free time! Here, we see a group of men playing a card game called Faro at the Orient Saloon in the town of Bisbee. Gambling was a common pastime in Tombstone as well..
Place your bets
Historica Graphica Collection / Heritage Images / Getty Images

A not-so-sleepy town

Before it became a part of Wild West folklore the sleepy town of Tombstone sure lived up to its name, as it only had about 100 residents at the turn of the 20th century. In the seven years following the town's silver mining boom, the population grew to 14,000, with plenty of outlandish incidents were soon to follow..
A not-so-sleepy town
Buyenlarge / Getty Images

Writing history

Here, we see Tombstone resident George Parsons, the man responsible for codifying much of the history of Tombstone during the peak of its Wild West exploits. A licensed attorney turned banker, it was Parsons' diary documenting life in Tombstone that became his lasting legacy..
Writing history
C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons

A special request

After meeting with Crook and C.S. Fly, Geronimo quickly developed a fondness for photography.
A special request
API / Gamma-Rapho / Getty Images
It was at Geronimo's request that Fly took this photograph of him with his fellow tribesmen. Here, Geronimo is seen mounted on his horse, with his son Tsisnah standing alongside him.

In the mines

All of the Wild West antics aside, the real reason for Tombstone's prosperity was its mining activity. Here, C.S.
In the mines
C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons
Fly photographed a team of mules hauling ore from the mines to a nearby stamping mill.

Early female leader

Pictured here is Samantha Fallon, owner of the San Jose House Hostel and a millinery shop in Tombstone. Samantha famously dated Tombstone founder Ed Schieffelin before the two wound up marrying other people..
Early female leader
u/Paul-Belgium / Reddit

Geronimo's surrender

In a truly surreal moment, C.S. Fly witnessed the appearance of this group of Apache warriors led by their brave leader Geronimo.
Geronimo's surrender
C.S. Fly / Library of Congress / Corbis / VCG / Getty Images
This photo was taken on March 27, 1886, just before Geronimo surrendered to General Crook in the Sierra Madre mountains of Mexico.

Gunfight at OK Corral

October 26, 1881, marked one of the most iconic moments in Wild West history. This was the day that Wyatt, Virgil, and Morgan Earp, along with their ally Doc Holiday defeated the notorious "Clanton Gang".
Gunfight at OK Corral
Arizona State Library, Archives and Public Records. History and Archives Division.
Here lies Tom McLaury, Frank McLaury, and Billy Clanton himself.

Peace talks

Before Geronimo's surrender to Crook, the terms of the deal had to be discussed. In what was a rarity in times of such tension, soldiers from General Crook's army sat together with Apache warriors to conduct peace talks..
Peace talks
C.S. Fly / Library of Congress / Corbis / VCG / Getty Images

Stay the night

Pictured in this landscape is the Grand Hotel, Tombstone's premier accommodation for weary travelers. Unfortunately, this establishment burned down in the great fire of 1882, though not before C.S.
Stay the night
C.S. Fly / Arizona Historical Society / Wikimedia Commons
Fly managed to cement its place in history.

A new home

Here, we see a group of young Apache children. At front and center is Santiago "Jimmy" McKinn — an 11 or 12-year-old boy who was captured by the Apaches near Silver City, New Mexico.
A new home
C.S. Fly / Library of Congress
Despite initially being held against his will, he was later unwilling to abandon his new home in favor of his old life.

Last man standing

Here, we see the ruins of the O.K. Corral, the scene of one of the most iconic shootouts of the Wild West era.
Last man standing
John van Hasselt / Sygma / Getty Images
Standing alongside the wreckage is Wyatt Earp, a central figure in the gunfight during which he and his fellow lawmen defeated a group of outlaws known as The Cowboys.

Prepared for anything

Prior to Geronimo's surrender, the US military wasn't sure what resistance to expect from the Apache leader. Here we see a company of US scouts, led by Lt.
Prepared for anything
C.S. Fly / The New York Historical Society / Getty Images
Marion Perry Maus, preparing to take on any trouble that might lie ahead.

Showing their pride

Here is yet another photo that was taken at Geronimo's request, featuring the great Apache leader along with some of his tribesmen. While not a chief of any tribe, Geronimo became one of the most famous Wild West figures due to his resilient leadership and military tactics..
Showing their pride
MPI / Getty Images

Up in flames

After C.S. Fly's death in 1901, his wife Mary decided to continue their shared photography efforts — that is until a fire destroyed the Flys' studio in 1915.
Up in flames
Mary Fly / Wikimedia Commons
Before leaving Tombstone for Los Angeles, Mary took this photo of the burning studio, a final memento of a life that once was.

💖 If you liked it, you should share it

✍ WRITTEN BY

Kyle Kucharski

Join Our Newsletter
Start your day with AbsoluteHistory
DMCA
Privacy policy
About
Terms of use
Contact us
CCPA Notice
Don't sell my personal information

Copyright © 2023 ContentIQ